Cayuga
NY
Average Sales Price
$535,543
Median Sales Price
$599,000
Population
2,460
Total Listings
7
Discover Life in Cayuga with Michael Slusser
Local Perspective
If I were walking a client through Cayuga, I would emphasize its unique blend of serene landscapes and community spirit. This area is often overlooked in the broader market, but I believe it offers an exceptional quality of life that many buyers are seeking. With its proximity to the Finger Lakes, Cayuga presents a perfect opportunity for those looking to escape the hustle and bustle while still being connected to nearby urban amenities. I frequently recommend Cayuga for its charm and affordability compared to neighboring areas.
Neighborhood Highlights
Cayuga boasts a tranquil atmosphere that feels both welcoming and vibrant. The area is distinct from nearby neighborhoods due to its picturesque lakefront views and a strong sense of community. You’ll find families enjoying the outdoors, retirees taking leisurely strolls, and creative types drawn to the natural beauty. Whether you’re looking for a quiet retreat or a place to engage with like-minded neighbors, Cayuga has something for everyone.
Buyer Fit & Lifestyle Match
Cayuga is perfect for families seeking a safe and nurturing environment to raise children, with ample parks and recreational activities. It also attracts retirees looking for a peaceful, scenic lifestyle without sacrificing community involvement. Young professionals, particularly those who work remotely, find the area appealing due to its affordability and access to nature. Creative individuals are drawn to the local arts scene, while investors see potential in the growing demand for vacation rentals given the area's proximity to the Finger Lakes.
Demographics
Data provided by Attom Data
Population
Employment
Population
2.5K
2.5K in 2020
Density
76
per square mile
Households
959
29 With Children
Gender
51% / 49%
Men Vs Women
Occupancy
82% / 18%
Owned Vs Rented
Age Median: -- Years
No Data
Education Level
No Data
Educational Environment
Elementary Schools (3)Middle Schools (2)
Name
Category
Grades
Library
Ratio
0/10
Frontenac Seventy-Day Adventist Elementary School
963 Spring Street Rd, Union Springs, NY 13160
Private
KG - 7
Yes
6:1 STUDENTS/TEACHERS
0/10
Cayuga Mennonite School
7329 Baldwin Rd, Cayuga, NY 13034
Private
1 - 8
No
9:1 STUDENTS/TEACHERS
0/10
Cayuga Elementary School
255 Wheat St, Cayuga, NY 13034
Public
KG - 3
No
16:1 STUDENTS/TEACHERS
Essential FAQs for Living in Cayuga
To help you make informed decisions, we've compiled answers to some of the most commonly asked questions.

What types of homes are available in Cayuga?
Cayuga offers a diverse range of homes, including charming single-family residences, modern townhouses, and spacious waterfront properties. This variety caters to different lifestyles and budgets, making it an attractive option for many buyers.
How's the commute from Cayuga?
Is Cayuga walkable?
What’s the market pace like?
How are the schools in Cayuga?
Are there HOA fees in Cayuga?






